Carl asked what I thought of that movie. I think he's trying to coax me to be a better blogger. I answered him in the Comments section, but Kat has convinced me to make it a bona fide post. So here it is.
I didn't like it at first, and it ultimately wasn't what it claimed to be - that is a musical odyssey through the south (or perhaps that's merely what I claimed it to be?) since the same faces kept popping up over and over again - primarily the Handsome Family and Johnny Dowd. But it did have something - I'll get to that in a minute.

Very nice was Melissa Swingle showing up and playing the saw like a master, and then telling a sad and funny story without a HINT of mirth. Almost worth the price of admission that was, right down to the two figures who walked out of the woods to listen to her play. I knew that was staged but I didn't mind.

A lot of stuff was staged, in fact, in the beginning, and I wasn't sure I was going to like the company of Jim White. But he grew on me. The movie was more a reflection on the hole that religion fills down there than a musical cornucopia, and he was really good at talking about that; there was only just enough live music in fact to make you reflect that music is a more tasteful, subtle and hell I suppose artistic means of filling that hole.

Near the end there was an interview with old man Lee Sexton as he spoke of working in the mines and playing the banjo to lift his spirit, and you believed him, and he also spoke of all the good banjo players who had died, including (it sounded like) his own father and his own son. I thought, if this wants to be a Southern Musical Odyssey, it's got to have a lot more stuff like this.
I think a true Southern Musical Odyssey wd have to be a whole series - like the Civil War Mini Series. This format could never really capture it all, no more than Oh Brother Where Art Thou. Making Johnny Dowd and the Handsome Family follow them around through the south had the opposite effect of what they wanted. Not that there's a master in every county, but that there are these few cuty-pie weirdos lurking around the whole place. No matter how good they were. Funny - it was the same flaw in Oh Brother.
Made me reflect on just how good The Buena Vista Social Club really was - that movie could be called Shakespearean in its scope. Seems like a weird thing to say about a musical documentary about Cuba, but it really was a unified portrait of a whole society (it seemed) of musicians, from the kings and queens down to the fops and the grooms.
This one clearly was made with love and a lot of cranes. Maybe they would have driven further if they'd used a smaller camera.

Still, it was good. Kat liked it a lot. As a portrait of southern religion it was actually quite profound and chilling. A woman preaching in a diner about the murderer who could already feel his feet burning before he died; the chinless radio-preacher who had such uncanny power that she nearly had the audience in the rep cinema speaking in tongues; and the visions of people speaking in tongues themselves, something I've never heard before. The characters in this movie want to convince you about the reality of hellfire, and they have such authority in the matter that they very nearly do, certainly more than anything else I've seen...

Soundtrack was great though. No doubt about that.