
Why do so many writers play the banjo? Among my own acquaintances there is Ann-Marie who purchased a banjo after she finished her novel and became my banjo student, displayed an admirable learning curve for awhile and then stopped practising. And there is André who, when the American rights to his novel were sold and after he had taken his daughter out for a shopping spree at the Gap, celebrated his good fortune by going out and getting himself a - yes - He was going to buy a pen, but a good friend so successfully mocked the choice for its practicality, its economy, its unacceptable humility, that he was forced to reconsider: "What do you really want to get for yourself?" she asked. "What is the one single thing in all the world that you would like to have for yourself right now, without considering the cost?"
I started playing the banjo in 1992. One July day I was wandering up Brunswick Avenue, heading nowhere in particular. At the corner of Bloor Street there was a band playing - a jug band - the sort of ensemble that includes a washboard and a stand-up bass fashioned from a bucket, a mop handle and a long piece of string. Right in the middle of a scrum of eight or ten enthusiasts stood this guy with a banjo. He was rock solid and motionless - a stance I've come to associate with bluegrass banjo players - eyes downcast, the expression on his face somewhere between boredom and intense concentration. Here was a fancy virtuoso with precision-tool nimble fingers, and his name was Christopher Quinn. (He now plays with the excellent bluegrass ensemble, Foggy Hogtown Boys - not to mention the Crazy Strings Wednesday night jams at the Silver Dollar, no cover.) I could go on and on now about the miracle of this bluegrass picker's art, but in truth it wasn't the stance of the player or even his technique that captivated me. It was the instrument itself: a wooden O with a white skin stretched over it, a stringed and fretted neck sticking out one side, and a middle-pitched almost nasal vocal sound coming straight out the front. I was imprinted, right on the spot. That wooden O was beating a path to my door, it was the open mouth of a chick in a nest. I had to ask myself: Whence this power?
The banjo came from Africa, across the Atlantic to America on the slave ships. American musicologists call it their only indigenous instrument. This of course is only true if you accept the Ellis Island vision of America, and since the slave ships never stopped at Ellis Island, one might find the idea of indigenous hard to swallow. Still, there is some truth to the claim: The sound that is associated with the banjo was created across the world. A Celtic tradition of lyrical ballads came across from the North. An African tradition of rhythm and drone came across from the South. Of course there's rhythm and drone in the north and lyricism in the south, but the truth of the matter is, these traditions did collide in the American South. They pounded against each other and caused centuries of pain, and they were captured in this Wooden O and became fused, creating a whole new sound and a symbol of the possibility inherent in such cultural collisions. The banjo a mongrel of a thing. Eventually tossed away by African American Culture in favour of fresher innovations, it was picked up by the cowboy hats, the Monroe Doctrine Boys, the bluegrass chewers and pickers, and carried on though the Twentieth Century.
So there I was, July at the corner of Bloor and Brunswick, fairly bursting with the desire to have an O of my own. It was a Saturday, late afternoon, and I knew that most music stores were going to close in an hour and were going to stay closed all the next day. What's more I knew that, come Monday morning, this irrational fever that presently gripped me would pass and I would very easily be able to talk myself out of making such a foolhardy purchase. You're a grown man, I would say to myself. You haven't got time to take up a whole new pursuit. You've never played an instrument in your life. You haven't got the aptitude. You haven't the patience. Your fingers will hurt. You can't afford it. It's a pipe dream. Friends and family will take you for a fool. It'll be a pain to lug around. You'll probably leave it on the subway. This is just the sort of half-cocked idea that causes you to go out and waste your money. You'll probably break it or something. Snap a string and not know how to fix it. Somebody will steal it. It'll get burned up in a fire. Wrecked on an airplane trip. Better not to get too attached to anything. Better not commit to anything that will just disappoint you later.
But it wasn't Monday morning yet: It was still late Saturday afternoon, and now I was thinking: If it doesn't work you can always resell it. With this sudden passion you can learn how to play this thing. It will give you a public face, be the extroverted part of yourself, a compensation for your bland writerly habits. You'll have something to do at parties. You'll be able to entertain your ailing mother. You'll be able to accompany your girlfriend's guitar. You'll be one of those people who play an instrument. You'll have a friend in old age, a companion to sail you through any doubt or disease or loneliness or despair. It will be your flotation device. It will be the thing that you do for yourself. It will teach you how to sing and to speak. You will write songs. Friends will seek you out. You will cheer people up. You'll be loved.
Tick tick tick. Long and McQuaid was located on the southwest corner of Ossington and Bloor or thereabouts. I grabbed a cab. I didn't have a lot of money but, having never purchased a stringed instrument of any kind before, I presumed the cost would not be proscriptive. I figured about eighty dollars. I was wrong of course, but it didn't matter: I was still in the grip. It wasn't Monday morning. I was ready to change my life. In the store I discovered that I was going to have to pay over two hundred dollars for a mere factory-made banjo. An aluminum O instead of a wooden O. Low-end tuning pegs. An unsupple head. It wasn't nearly so appealing as the one I'd seen in the street. Still I was in the grip. Then the price jumped to three hundred to include the case. Plus another twenty for strings and instruction book. I would have to go to the bank machine across the street. Three hundred dollars, spelling the difference between a banjo and not.
There was no contest. The difference between Saturday Night and Monday morning said it all. As I walked out of the store in possession of my new aluminum O they flipped the sign on the door from 'Open' to 'Closed.' Come Monday morning, rather than accounting for a Saturday impulse nipped in the bud, I was attempting to learn the old-time and bluegrass standard "Old Joe Clark."
Old Joe Clark had a house
Sixteen storeys high,
Every room in that big house
Was filled with chicken pie
I was hooked. I bought so many books on the art of Clawhammer Banjo that I very nearly didn't make rent. I quickly discovered that I actually knew something about all this. I'd been raised with records of American Folk Music and Minstrelsy: Pete Seeger. The Weavers. Hedy West. East Virginia. The State of Arkansas. Cotton Mill Girls. There was a lot of banjo on there, not in the intricate and impressive ensemble blugras style, but rather the simple ancient solo style that I suddenly found myself aching to play: Frailing. A.k.a. Clawhammer. A.k.a. rapping: A downpicking cross between melody and rhythm that finds the right hand thwacking exuberantly across the strings. Well-nigh impossible to explain on paper. In Theatre School, studying to be an actor, I'd seen a classmate a year above me play this style on his banjo in a show. Paul Miller. The instrument had given him such authority in my eyes. He lived in Toronto. I called him up. He came over one day and played with me. Sat back and sighed with satisfaction as I attempted my rudimentary version of Worried Man Blues. "That's real music," he said, as if it were a rare phenominon to be in the presence of such. To hear such. And it was coming from me.
Yes I was hooked. Three months after puchasing the aluminum O I journeyed over to The Twelfth Fret out on the Danforth and traded that one in (plus nine hundred dollars) for the one I have now - a Canadian-made Neufeld banjo with an open back, ebony fretboard, mother of pearl inlay and curly maple neck. The true blue wooden O. Now I wasn't just hooked: I was in love.
Everything I've learned about Stan Neufeld, the maker of my banjo: Lived just outside of Toronto for awhile. Was a part of the folk revival in the early seventies. Started making banjos. Mine appears to have been made in 1980, if the serial number is any indication. Made mandolins too, but apparently they're not as good as his banjos. His brother-in-law is Toronto pianist John Hess who owns the first banjo he ever made. His wife (John's sister) did the fancy mother-of-pearl inlay work on the necks of all the banjos he made. He quit making instruments in the 80's because he couldn't really make a living at it and moved out to B.C. where he now works as a building contractor. As a further note, all this information was contradicted one day by a man who walked up to me while I was busking on Queen Street: He said he knew the maker of my banjo. Said my man had played and made banjos for awhile in Peterborough and then moved down to the Southern Sates to become an itinerant preacher. How do you like them apples? Which story should I believe? I'll tell you: since I strive to embrace a pan-cultural vision of this wooden O and don't wish to see it pigeonholed as a folk instrument from a particular region of the United States, I tend to repeat the former story more often than the latter. And I imagine John Hess wouldn't lie about his sister's inlay work, or the occupation of the man she married.
The only other Neufeld Banjo I've seen is a bluegrass style (with a resonator to increase volume) owned by Winnipeg's Daniel Koulack, one of the great banjo players on the continent. A feature of both his and mine is the greater-than-average weight of the instrument, due to the concentration of wood in the fashioning of the pot.
I would gaze at the banjo from my bed, night after night, hanging there from a nail on my closet door. I would practise for six hours a day. Old Joe Clark. Jesse James. Groundhog. Wildwood Flower. Shady Grove. Ducks on the Millpond. John Hardy. Turkey in the Straw. Cluck Old Hen. Angeline the Baker. I played for my mother, who was sick. I did it to alleviate the boredom inherent in these visits home, but in truth she was the one who was bored: I must have played the same five songs a hundred times. She endured it though, content with the company. When she died I went into her bedroom and kissed her cheek and then withdrew to the cool darkness of the laundry room to play one last song for her. I hid because I was self-conscious. The rest of my family didn't know what to make of this new obsession of mine. I imagine they still don't. I just remember this instant what I played there: RedWing.
Then back to my city life. Cindy. Waterbound. Sugar Hill. Betty Liken. Little Rabbit. Kitchen Girl. A full year of this and my girlfriend left me. Who wouldn't, given the towering presence of this other love in my life? Following a period of bitterness in which a friend recalls I nearly threw it on top of the fire we'd made on a Lake Huron beach, I returned to the instrument with a new devotion. Soldier's Joy. The Big Scioty. Briar Picker Brown. I lived with a girl for awhile in Winnipeg. Played Sleeping Lulu in the morning, quietly, and managed not to wake her up. I was learning how to finesse. Started learning Canadian Songs: Lord Franklin. Wade Hemsworth's Blackfly, learned accidentally in a minor key. Foolish You. The Witch of the Westmoreland. One day my friends stopped shunning me. Started making requests. I no longer cleared a room. I was playing in public, sort of. Joined a stringband in Winnipeg. Mandolin. Guitar. Dulcimer. Fiddle. Accordian. All the other players were classical composers and singers and music professors who wanted to get a little of Paul Miller's 'real music' in on the side. They'd heard me play at a party and invited me to join them. I had to leave the city before we got out of the rehearsal stage. People told me that my voice had improved. I was becoming the player I wanted to be.
The songs I learned were simple and evocative, they left so much out of their stories and still succeeded in filling the canvas. They were down to earth. Perhaps that is the attraction to this troubador's instrument, the balladeer's instrument, to a writer: There's something ancient about it, and connected to the art of storytelling. It's reminicent of Homer's lute. Two writers I know, Joan McLeod and Patrick Freisen - both playwrights - told me once that they felt a singing, songwriting troubador has it all over the playwright in the sense that he can sit up there with his luthiered, stringed attendant and spin a tale from start to done in under five minutes. And then he can go on to spin another, and another. The playwright needs actors, lights, a stage, a script, sometimes even that very instrumentalist who can do it all on his own, strumming away in the background. There's more economy in this troubador's alternative than in André's choice of a pen. All you have to do is know how to play. And sing. And write. And sit up in front of people to tell a story with great authority. That is something writers dream of doing, even as they spread their words across a sheet of paper.
Still I don't think that's quite the reason. Players of the mandolin, the piano, the dulcimer, the bandore, the autoharp, the zither, the sitar, the lute, etc., can also exploit an audience's desire for music and a tale swiftly told. So many instruments have grace and beauty. They can take your breath away. But to me a banjo has presence of a singular nature, even if it's poorly made. It feels to me like human company. I'm drawn to it when I'm lonely, when I need a respite from writing. Perhaps it's the beckoning power of that O, symbol of the wheel, the vortex, the mind. Don't lay any violins across my path if there's a banjo in the room. Focus for me comes sometimes at a price. They might get stepped on. And the banjo doesn't sing the way other instruments do. It's pitched somewhat in the register of the human speaking voice. This makes it difficult to play with any resonance when people are talking; it feels then like everybody's talking at once. It's best played softly in a silent room. The banjo doesn't sing: It speaks. And when you, a writer, are all by yourself in a room, at a desk, for several hours at a stretch, and you start to get sick of the sound of your own voice in your head, you can pick it up and listen what it has to say. Depending on the tuning you find, it has a sense of humour, it's moody, can tell an epic tale or a bit of bombast and blarney. It can laugh, cry, wail, howl, moan, blaze, yip, whine, balk, scold, tease, rev, grin; Where the banjo is concerned, you may be playing it, but it does all the talking.
First Published in Number 63 of the
Brick Literary Journal. Written in the
Okanagan Valley. Edited by Michael Redhill. Reproduced with permission.